Lemon Law: After the “Don Lemon” Dark Money Mailers, Ethics Commission Weighs a Longer Electioneering Window
Mailings involved a Lawton group directed by Dustin Hilliary, Gov. Kevin Stitt’s senior adviser and chief negotiator with state lawmakers.
OKLAHOMA CITY, Okla. — (November 17, 2026) A collection of the dark-money “Don Lemon” mailers believed to have helped shape the outcome of Oklahoma’s 2026 Republican primary and runoff elections. The mailers were distributed without donor disclosure under a loophole exempting electioneering materials sent outside the final 30 days before an election.
Listen to this article
OKLAHOMA CITY — The Oklahoma Ethics Commission is weighing a rule that would require political groups to disclose who paid for certain ads earlier in the campaign. The proposal follows a wave of anonymous mailers attacking some of the Legislature’s most conservative members over votes against a bill that critics said could restrict sidewalk protests and the distribution of religious tracts.
Oklahoma Ethics Commission Executive Director Lee Anne Bruce Boone presented the proposal to commissioners at their Nov. 12 meeting. If adopted, it would extend the period before a primary in which groups must identify themselves on qualifying electioneering ads and report spending that meets the filing threshold. The window would widen from 30 days to 60 days.
The potential for abuse was highlighted by what became known as the “Lemon” attacks. The mailers, featuring former television host Don Lemon, began arriving with just 14 weeks remaining before the primary election and primed voters in key districts across the state, including districts where conservative incumbents faced challengers.
The mailers arrived in three flavors, all built around the same legislative vote:
- Praise for incumbent senators. These mailers backed members of Senate President Pro Tem Lonnie Paxton’s ruling coalition who faced conservative challengers. The postcards urged recipients to call and thank the senators for their votes and bore a Lawton, Oklahoma, mailing permit.
- A sarcastic thank-you. These mailers targeted conservative incumbents, purporting to praise their votes in a way that could make recipients think the cards came from a left-wing group. The postcards carried ordinary stamps and had no permit number.
- An attack from “Citizens for Freedom.” This version criticized conservatives who voted no. It bore a Denver, Colorado, bulk-mail permit and used the name Citizens for Freedom, for which no registration with the Oklahoma Ethics Commission has surfaced.
Journalist Katy Smith, writing for the V1SUT Substack, obtained postal records that identified the holder of the Lawton permit on a postcard praising Senate District 28 Sen. Grant Green. Green, a Paxton ally, went on to win the Republican primary by a narrow margin. The records identified the permit holder as Oklahoma Conservative Coalition, which used the Lawton address of Hilliary Communications. The coalition lists Gov. Kevin Stitt’s senior adviser and chief negotiator with state lawmakers, Dustin Hilliary, as one of its directors. The sponsors of the other two versions remain publicly unidentified.
The Oklahoma Ethics Commission discussed the cards at its April 9 meeting without taking a formal vote. Staff received guidance to continue examining the issue and possible changes to disclosure rules. Staff discussed whether the pieces fell outside the rules that require senders of “electioneering” ads to disclose who paid for them.
Electioneering ads are ads that promote or criticize a candidate without expressly calling for the candidate’s election or defeat. A mailer might ask recipients to call and thank a lawmaker for a vote, without saying “vote for the candidate.”
The current narrow window gives dark money groups plenty of time to spot developing races and intervene before the electioneering rules can require disclosure of who paid for the ads, how much the group spent or which vendors it used.
By June, disclosures showed the Lawton coalition spending large amount of money in some of the same races the earlier mailers had primed. Members of the Hilliary family also gave thousands of dollars directly to their preferred candidates.
The ethics commission will next review the proposal at 10 a.m. Dec. 3 in Room G-3 at the State Capitol.
Independent journalism like this is made possible by paid subscribers to The Oklahoma State Capital Substack. If you found this story valuable and believe in The Capital's mission to tell the side of the story often ignored by corporate media, consider becoming a paid subscriber. Your support helps fund future journalism and gives you early access to exclusive features.
Subscribe today: by clicking here.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Join the conversation
Sign in with your OSC account to comment on this story and reply to other readers.