“I Thought We Were a Red Brick Community”
Guthrie City Council unanimously grants business owner Jennifer Bozarth’s appeal, clearing the way for her to restore the McNulty Building’s brick facade.
GUTHRIE, Okla. — (November 17, 2026) Guthrie business owner Jennifer Bozarth presents her appeal to the City Council on Tuesday night. Bozarth prevailed as councilors voted unanimously to overturn the Guthrie Historic Preservation Commission’s refusal to allow her to restore the brick facade of the McNulty Building at 220 E. Harrison Ave.
Listen to this article
GUTHRIE, Okla. — Guthrie business owner Jennifer Bozarth found a much friendlier audience at City Hall on Tuesday night as she brought her appeal to the Guthrie City Council. The outcome never appeared in doubt as Bozarth asked the council to overturn the Historic Preservation Commission’s 4–3 decision blocking her from restoring the brick facade of the McNulty Building at 220 E. Harrison Ave.
Bozarth had been before the commission repeatedly since June, after removing the building’s Vitrolite glass tiles over safety concerns. The commission had approved an Art Deco-style stucco finish and rejected her request to leave the brick exposed.
“I thought we were a red brick community,” said Ward 2 Councilman Brian Bothroyd, who had reviewed footage of the commission’s meetings. Bothroyd said it was the second time a matter of this kind had come before the council. He asked City Manager Eddie Faulkner to put an item on the next meeting’s agenda so the council could consider changing the historic preservation ordinance to bring all major facade requests before the council.
Ward 1 Councilwoman Deanna Duehning appeared perplexed by the commission’s insistence on an Art Deco-style stucco finish.
“Why are we pulling the stucco card?” she asked.
Mayor Adam Ropp said he believed at least two commissioners would have voted differently had they had all the information before them. He said the commission had done the best it could with the information it had and suggested that researching the building’s history in depth was outside its role. Ropp has previously served on the Commission.
Bozarth expressed frustration, saying the commission had been dismissive of the information she had provided and described being told that the brick wasn't suitable for an exterior facade. Bozarth would later learn, after contacting industry experts, that it was.
No commissioner appeared to speak in defense of the decision leaving just Bozarth and Erin Brown, curator of collections at the Oklahoma Territorial Museum, who spoke about the building’s history before the council voted unanimously to grant the appeal.
Ward 3 Councilman Grant Aguirre and Ward 1 Councilwoman Menecca Gibbs, the council’s ex officio representative on the commission, were absent.
The appeal took up much of the council’s 41-minute meeting. The council also took up proposed agreements with Myers Engineering and Poe & Associates to provide on-call engineering services. The agreements were subject to the city attorney’s approval.
The council’s next regular meeting is set for 6:30 p.m. Tuesday, Dec. 1, at City Hall.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Join the conversation
Sign in with your OSC account to comment on this story and reply to other readers.