LOADING

Guthrie Citizen Journalist Uncovers Data Sharing by Guthrie City Hall With Federal Agency

A Sooner Sentinel investigation revealed Guthrie’s traffic scanners feed data to Amazon servers, where federal agencies, including the ATF, can access and retain it for unknown purposes.

Feature Picture For This Story

CRESCENT, OKLAHOMA, December 15, 2024 — Citizen journalist Marven Goodman looks on as a presenter addresses a meeting of Logan County property owners. In January, Goodman broke the story revealing that the ATF had been given access to Guthrie's surveillance system.

Share

Link to or share this article at www.oklahomastatecapital.com/s/5cff22d386b7

Listen to this article

The travels of Guthrie residents may have been the subject of warrantless surveillance by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) as far back as 2023.

The revelation comes courtesy of the startup publication The Sooner Sentinel, via its platform on Substack.

On Thursday, The Sentinel published a comprehensive listing of agencies, including the ATF, that have access to conduct searches of Guthrie's traffic, as monitored by an array of approximately 12 surveillance scanners.

The scanners, approved, albiet with some hesitation, by the Guthrie City Council in 2022, establish a biometric profile of each passing vehicle. The data is sent to Amazon Web Services servers, where Guthrie City Hall appears to allow nearly 100 government agencies, including the ATF, to search, potentially download, and retain that data for an unknown period of time on their own separate computer systems.

In a 2022 meeting, Guthrie Ward II City Councilman Brian Bothroyd theorized that the scans could allow Guthrie Police to conduct a door-to-door dragnet of residents until the police identified the owner of a scanned vehicle.

The Sentinel's publisher, former Logan County Commissioner turned citizen journalist Marven Goodman, discovered the sharing policy after filing an open records request with City Hall.

The sharing policy was only briefly referenced during the Council's deliberations on the proposal in 2022. Its extent appears to have likely been unclear to council members, including at least two who expressed concern about the idea. Goodman is working to determine whether council members were fully aware of the sharing arrangement or if they had been informed of the ATF's access.

In the fall, Goodman played a key role in an interim study conducted by the Oklahoma House of Representatives. He was recognized to testify on the matter and revealed Guthrie's use of the scanning devices on State Highway 33. The state's Department of Transportation does not have the authority to permit such devices on state highways, and within hours of his testimony before the committee, the devices were removed.

Goodman's disclosure comes just two days after outgoing Logan County Commissioner Charlie Meadows used his final county commission meeting to criticize Goodman, who was covering the meeting. Meadows suggested Goodman may run for commissioner and said it would be a "huge mistake" for voters to elect Goodman over Sharpton, a longtime Meadows ally.

For the second consecutive meeting, Goodman was the only media representative covering the commission meeting, as Guthrie News Page's Chris Evans was not in attendance.

Article short link

Link to or share this article at www.oklahomastatecapital.com/s/5cff22d386b7

Jason W. Murphey

Have something to add?

Contact this writer

Jason W. Murphey covers City Desk, Crime, Public Affairs and Public Corruption

If you would like to weigh in on this story with the writer, or if you know of other stories worth looking at — write to Jason directly. Reporters would rather hear from you than not, and a tip from somebody who was actually there beats a week of open records requests.

Prefer the newsroom? (405) 260‑9966, press 6 · news@oklahomastatecapital.com · all the ways to reach us

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Join the conversation

Sign in with your OSC account to comment on this story and reply to other readers.

Sign In
GUTHRIE NWS
NOW 75°F Clear WIND NNE 3 mph TODAY 95°F Partly Sunny · 12% rain TONIGHT 71°F Mostly Clear · 9% rain CIMARRON 4.96 ft steady COTTONWOOD 2.25 ft falling SUN 6:55 am – 8:06 pm
OSC LIVE

UPDATE THE CURBSIDE SOUTHBOUND LANE OF DIVISION STREET IS CLOSED AT THE NEW MCDONALD’S CONSTRUCTION SITE AS LARGE CREWS CONTINUE WORKING ON THE PROJECT. UPDATE ALL-STATE GAMES BOOST EDMOND: THE OKLAHOMA COACHES CLINIC AND ALL-STATE GAMES BROUGHT HUNDREDS OF ATHLETES AND THOUSANDS OF VISITORS TO EDMOND. THE EVENT IS SET TO RETURN FOR THE NEXT TWO YEARS. UPDATE EDMOND OKS MORE LEGACY HOUSING: THE EDMOND CITY COUNCIL APPROVED UP TO 850 APARTMENTS AND TOWNHOMES AT LEGACY AT COVELL, AS DEVELOPERS SAY ADDED HOUSING WILL SUPPORT THE PROJECT’S EXPANDING RETAIL PLANS. BREAKING LOGAN COUNTY BURN BAN: COMMISSIONERS APPROVED A COUNTYWIDE BURN BAN FOR UP TO 14 DAYS AS SEVERE-TO-EXTREME DROUGHT CONDITIONS CONTINUE. NOTICE THE OKLAHOMA STATE CAPITAL HAS OPENED APPLICATIONS FOR ITS FIRST-EVER STANDING VOTER PANEL, AN INITIATIVE DESIGNED TO GIVE GRASSROOTS VOTERS A PUBLIC VOICE IN OKLAHOMA’S STATEWIDE POLICY DIALOGUE.